NDD versus ECN versus STP - Page 3
Page 3 of 733 FirstFirst 123
Results 21 to 22 of 322

Thread: NDD versus ECN versus STP

  1. #21
    I discovered this in a book it explains all about ECN, I hope it will help :
    ECN is short for Electronic Communiions Network, and Foreign Exchange brokers who fall into this egory will usually charge a small trading commission or fee. Bear in mind, there's absolutely no such thing as a free lunch, and whilst 'trading' may appear attractive keep in mind that the prices will probably probably be concealed from the spreads. The ECN broker can be considered transparent. You've paid for a service, the trade, and the broker has left his or her cash. In many ways this is like trading stocks or futures. You are charged a commission and the trade is executed. An ECN broker in the Foreign Exchange world operates in the exact same way. They provide Foreign Exchange traders with a marketplace where all the participants, however large or small, can trade against each other by sending competing bids and offers into the system. In some ways, you can think about this as a 'exchange' there traders buy and sell in complete anonymity and with transparency. All orders are matched between counter parties in real time, however in order to get a Foreign Exchange trading broker to be classified as a genuine ECN, the brokerage must display something called DOM or 'Depth of Market' in an information window, to show customers their particular order size inside the system, and allow
    other customers to trade against these orders. In other words, Foreign Exchange traders should be able to see the liquidity, and execute transactions. Put simply, it means transparency!
    ECN brokers will always offer varying spreads, and since they don't make their money on the spread between the bid and the ask, any trading fashion (including scalping) ought to be permitted. Some Foreign Exchange brokers do not permit this style of trading, and as you will see, when we reach the questions to ask, this can be on the list. In the past couple of years, the conditions of trading have shifted dramatically and also there are questions you need to ask before opening your account to guarantee your style of trading is permitted by the broker.
    An ECN broker can therefore be considered, in my opinion at any rate, as the purest type of broker. They make their money from your commissions charged and are therefore eager for their clients. After all, if you are successful you'll trade more actively and generate more commissions to the broker. It is a win/win situation. However, many new Foreign Exchange traders have been 'sold' on the benefit of 'free' trading, and fail to realize the advantages of paying a small commission in return for a honest and transparent trading environment. It's only when Foreign Exchange traders have experienced their stops being hit 'market
    spikes', absurd market moves against their rankings, and endless 'server problems', these same traders start to appreciate the benefits of a legitimate ECN broker.

  2. #22
    In my opinion there are only 2 broker kinds, A-Book (ECN, STP etc) and B-Book (Market manufacturers).

    ECN, STP, NDD are all just fancy phrases and abbreviations brokers use to confuse traders into thinking they have multiple account types when really they are just reserving everything except the highly profitable traders.

    I've spoken to a lot of brokers and that I can not tell you how many claim to be ECN when they're not. Technically I think they can claim to be ECN even though one trade is actually going through to market and then they'll slap ECN all around the place as though they're Christmas.

    Do your research on brokers, talk to people, read reviews (not in their own site) and ask the brokers straight up the difficult questions:
    Are you 100 percent ECN? Can you ship all trades to be filled by liquidity suppliers? ....

    Anyways, just my 2 cents.

    Cheers,
    Piplife

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to store session information to facilitate remembering your login information, to allow you to save website preferences, to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.