The Ultimate Guppy Multiple Moving Average (GMMA) Thread
Page 1 of 732 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 315

Thread: The Ultimate Guppy Multiple Moving Average (GMMA) Thread

  1. #1
    Id like to begin this thread for Guppy traders to talk and learn. I have recently come across this method of analysis and would like to learn from other experienced members.


    Intro into the GMMA
    http://www.chartfilter.com/articles/movingaverage.htm
    The old GMMA thread with some valuable information and hyperlinks
    https://www.forexsoutheast.asia/gene...t-systems.html

  2. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Do not know why a few of you require MACD with GMMA.
    MACD itself can be based on MAs, therefore it useless and contrasts all, for my opinion.
    Not sure when Guppy traders are posting any longer but I exchange the GMMA on Oanda's 3H and so far so good but too early to determine if I have the hang of this. Daryl Guppy's book Trend Trading is about the GMMA to use it. And he does not enjoy the RSI MACD - adds nothing. Approx. 6 mos. I attempted this egy and did not do well but I had not analyzed Guppy's bible and I have not been a scalper. Thus the 3H. It may also try in my setup but also the acct. Is far down as I want I can not put SLs. See if I could be successful on the 1H with TPs and stops. Fantastic trading all

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Not certain when Guppy traders are posting any more but I exchange the GMMA on Oanda's 3H so far so good but too early to determine if I have the hang of it. Daryl Guppy's publication Trend Trading is all about the GMMA how to use it....
    Well I cant say im a guppy trader, however, I'm a moving average trader. I think its operation, its the indior. I think ive heard a lot from the guppy trading, the rainbow thread and Linuxtrolls articles. I dont attempt to mimic any trading fashion I produce my own, and I think that is the thing to do. Talk, listen, learn, develop, analyze and come up with things bit by bit and attempt to understand price in a private fashion, thats exactly what I think functions.

    A couple of months ago I experimented using MAs, trying to come up with something that acts as shifting S/R, and after many weeks I discovered a few that appears to do the trick. I came up like the ones Linuxtroll propopsed in the Guppy thread. Ive looked at that ichimoku kinko hyo stuff and the idea behind it was to capture zones of S/R, but I wasnt able to make it work. Instead I made S/R zones from the old MAs I discovered months ago. As it turned out they arent the ones I think thats a good thing, and that I have seen anyone usage, I think everybody needs to find their way sounds a bit prophetic but I cant see how it would workout.

    As Linuxtroll was saying in the old thread, it would seem exactly the same MAs could be implemented pretty much on any timeframe, because its more a way of thinking about price then anything else.

    Generally I just try to look for a fad, when fast a slow group align, and if that happens im in my feet. And when fashion reverses I wait 1 candle and then I enter if price is inside a S/R zone. When this occurs price overshoots the reverse in 95% of all cases and there is room for some fairly safe profits. It would seem its basically not more difficult then .

  4. #4
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Well I cant say im a guppy trader, but I'm a moving average trader. I believe its simple indior. I believe ive learned a lot from the rainbow thread the guppy trading and Linuxtrolls articles. I dont try to mimic any additional trading fashion, rather I produce my own, and I believe that is the way to go. Talk, listen, learn, create, analyze and produce things bit by bit and try to comprehend price in a personal manner, thats exactly what I believe works.

    A few weeks back I experimented...
    Not sure I know: are the MAs that the S/R zones or do you utilize the more conventional way? For Placing, and exactly what TF, my 3H would require more than one candle. Thanks for adding to the knowledge base

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Not sure I understand: are the MAs that the S/R zones or would you use the more traditional way? For reversing and what TF, my 3H would require more than one candle. Thank you for adding to the knowledge base, p.
    I use both traditionl S/R levels, readily spotted historically on high timeframes. S/R zones are the kind Linuxtroll and Guppy MAs are, therefore the MAs are all to moving zones, pursuing price, tugging and pulling at it because it goes along. Im trading M1, I go where I can calculate the best so thats where I go.

  6. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    . And when fashion reverses I wait one candle and then I enter if price is within a S/R zone. When this happens price overshoots the reverse in 95 percent of cases.
    Not sure what this means--can you post a screenshot--and also feel free not to exhibit the ma interval values which I know that you worked hard to develop with and ought to stay proprietary.

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    not sure what this means--can you post a screenshot--and also feel free to not display the ma interval values that I know you worked hard to develop with and should remain proprietary.
    Sorry I didnt see your post sooner, but here it goes. I work pretty quickly so I forget what I did a day or two 17, I believe.

    The S/R zones I was refering to is the MAs, they build kind of a zone, so its not well defined, its not accurate its just kind of a zone, you dig?

    Well in general you're trying to input as price becomes back into the trend. So the thing would be to have the ability to spot just some partial weakening of trend behaviour and the difference between a change. You should always think about that other people that is about as smart as you're considering price, trying to outsmart you.

    You can attempt to input when you have observed the crimson mas stretch out, and go into the other colours and attempt to enter as price is getting out of these, or if you have good reason for you may attempt to input while price is still in the MAs. That location can also be a divergence location, so then you know lots of EAs are considering that divergence of CCI, and they will buy right there where the green arrow is. They keep their trade for 20 seconds so they will need to see some action should you do so for weeks and months you might get skille to determine when exactly that is and attempt to enter together.

    I have learned to observe the difference between EAs doing their thing and dimwitted individuals big company, its not to hard, some people have as much cash they dont care that much if they win they enter at stupid places, occasionally 100 miljon of base currency which makes waves and stuff in price.

    But I mean read Linxutrolls stuff, along with the rainbow thread and stuff like this, its not super easy to get really good at it, it will probably take you at least several months for to break even in the event that you dont have knowledge from previous events which are very near this understanding or maybe in the event that you try meditating or using both sides of your mind at once if can be faster.

    I dont trade this template but I trade this manner of thinking. Anyhow there's more and less tangible and important MAs and if you're patient you'll find them if you go through outdated information and see what places price has trouble going through, is it due to MAs or because of fixed S/R such as dailys and stuff? Well youll have to figure out that, attempt 100 MAs and eliminate everyone that doesnt appear to be in the method of price. That process took me about 1 month to find ones.

    There's also S/R that is not MAs and not fixed amount S/R, this is EAs buying and selling like crazy, trying to strike bottoms and tops, going anti-trend all the time. If you trade quickly you should make an effort and make the most of this. In the big picture that type of S/R doesnt really exist, or works in a manner that is different I must say.

    In the beginning I would recommend using maybe 3 positions demonstration, dont worry about SL in the start, place it really safe like 50 pips, and just try to generate some profit and dont worry about the losses. When you get some profit you go back and attempt to see what you did and repeat this. When you get good at that is as soon as you can utilize one position or tripple SL when compared with TP. When im I have fixed TP but most of the time I shut before that. Get scripts, has posted all you will need a while ago. I couldnt commerce without them because I have about ten seconds to get in great on a deal ahead of the EAs swarm the place.

    A thing such as a CCI isnt a one way road, its pretty complied to learn how to read it, I mean if its raising, you DONT need to market, if its diminishing you DONT want to buy, you want to see that it quits and goes towards 0 most of the time until you input.

    When price moves you way withouth much in the way that people are agreeing exactly what to do right? Well you can indie this in advance and if its happening in the event that you use all you have between your shoulders. Happy pipping anyhow, its holiday now I wasnt supposed to be functioning.

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    not certain what this means--can you post a screenshot--and also feel free not to exhibit the ma period values that I know you worked hard to come up with and should remain proprietary.
    Hey simpletrades - if you want the definitive explanations of GMMA then buy Daryl Guppy's Trend Trading. It is dedicated to MMAs and the way they act and interact. I got mine and also for significantly less than what Wiley Press charges. The illustrations, and there are many, are longer term - day, weekly, etc. although the analysis and chart notations could be applied to any TF. I started out to the 3H but have been doing more scalping. Also Google his name, lots of stuff there but make certain that you winnow out what other people say and pay attention to Mr. Guppy. Once reading the MAs are down pat it is a good egy. p.

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by ;
    Hey simpletrades - if you want the definitive explanations of GMMA then buy Daryl Guppy's Trend Trading....
    I dont think I might recommend that book if you trade M1. I am rather reluctant to novels such as that, I don't read any one of im and em OK. I trust what I can see and verify and compute, that works in the long run.

  10. #10
    I exchange mostly although the 3H the 5M 1M. The publication can add groundwork and background . De

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
This website uses cookies
We use cookies to store session information to facilitate remembering your login information, to allow you to save website preferences, to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.